Conventional
|
Inactivated/Killed |
Physically or chemically manipulated microbe which loses its ability to infect/replicate
|
-
Less expensive to produce compared to other types
-
Stable under different conditions
|
-
Requires use of adjuvants as induced immunity is weaker/short-lived
-
Toxic/systemic reactions to adjuvants
-
Less immunogenic
|
Inactivated Infectious Salmon Anemia Virus (ISAV)
|
Attenuated live vaccine
|
Modified virus/bacteria with low virulence for the fish species
|
-
More immunogenic compared to killed vaccine
-
Long lasting immunity
|
- Risks associated with virulence
-
Contamination with other live microorganisms
|
Attenuated Arthrobacter vaccine against bacterial kidney disease (BKD)
|
Alternative Vaccine Technologies
|
Subunit
|
Use of antigenic/immunogenic parts
|
-
Highly characterized
-
Allows easier transport (can be freeze-dried)
|
- Requires adjuvants as associated with low immunogenicity
- May require multiple immunizations (higher labor requirements)
|
G glycoprotein for Spring viremia of carp virus
|
VLPs
|
Mofidied subunit vaccine comprise of viral capsid and target proteins
|
- High immunogenicity
- No reversion to virulence compared to live vaccine
- Allows chimeric VLPs
|
- May be unstable during downstream processing
- Variable expression in different host systems
|
Nervous necrosis virus (NNV) VLP vaccines
|
DNA
|
Plasmid which carries gene coding for antigenic protein
|
- Activate strong immunity
- Rapid development
- Considered safer than whole organism
|
- Needs protection for entry
- Risk of insertion into the genome
|
DNA vaccine against IHNV
|
DNA vaccine against IHNV
|
Can be non-amplifying or self-amplifying
|
- No risk for infection or insertion
- Stimulates strong immunity
|
- In-vitro transcription may be expensive
- Optimal delivery is challenging
|
Vaccine candidate only: Salmonid alphavirus 3 (SAV3)-based replicaon against ISAV
|